Ever since I heard a teacher argue about the importance of computers in education, Iâ€™ve been thinking about how much I disagree. Sure, weâ€™re moving towards a world of technological advancement, and computers surround us and affect us in our daily lives, but to start children on computers at an early age is something that I donâ€™t think the schools should be responsible for. Itâ€™s my opinion that children should learn basic reading, writing, and arithmetic skills before tackling the mouse and keyboard.
Since then, Iâ€™ve started thinking about how technology affects us. Most of us canâ€™t live without things like e-mail, the Internet, or even word processing. I was shocked to find ledger paper in my office the other day (you know, the columnar paper that accountants used to record credits and debits on before they could do it with a computer). Iâ€™m frightened at how dependent we are on all of this technology.
“Wait a minute Brianâ€¦ youâ€™re a gear head! Youâ€™ve got all kinds of gadgets and suchâ€¦ how can you say youâ€™re frightened of technology?”
Itâ€™s true. Iâ€™m almost as bad as the next person. You realize that there are times that I need to perform calculations in my head (I leave my calculator in my desk drawer, often by mistake). But itâ€™s also part of my past. When I worked in a hardware store, the cash register was so old that we actually had to punch in the numbers along a grid of digits (unlike the little keyboards you find on most registers and calculators today). The register didnâ€™t tell us the change; we had to figure that out in our minds. So imagine the amazement a cashier had at a nearby restaurant when she keyed in the wrong button on her register and I had to tell her how much my change was. This is another example of how technology is adversely affecting us.
With the invention of the pocket calculator and its decreasing price, teachers have found it necessary to require children to use these for some simple math. Sure, I went to school after the slide rule was obsolete, and yes, I was required to purchase a graphing calculator for school (and they were new technology back then). But when college started, the calculator was shunned, if not completely banished, from the classroom. Imagine taking a test and having to multiply numbers on the piece of paper that youâ€™re working onâ€¦ and these chicken scratches were actually required! Can most children do this today?
Today, we also have less expensive computers (well, compared to what they cost before the mid-nineties). Most parents think that computers are actually positive influences on their childrenâ€™s learning. So, letâ€™s see if I understand thisâ€¦ a six-year old boy or girl should learn how to use a keyboard, right? Imagine those tiny fingers typing as fast as I canâ€¦ and Iâ€™m no speed-typist. Or they should learn how to read things on a screen. I have two words for you: eye strain. I canâ€™t believe that children would learn any faster using a computer than if they were reading a book. Yes, I believe that children should be exposed to technology, but only after they have the fundamentals down. For generations, children learned by reading books, writing with pencils, and adding with their fingers. But letâ€™s teach them that computers will do all the work for themâ€¦ thatâ€™s what I call learning.
Wait, I havenâ€™t mentioned the Internet yet. It seems that everyone out there thinks the Internet is the ultimate source of information. I recently saw a Charter Communications commercial where some kidâ€™s bad grades were the result of getting rid of a dial-up Internet connection, but his grades went back up when he used his friendâ€™s high-speed Internet connection. What school does he attend that doesnâ€™t have a library (Books? What are those?)?
I remember when the Internet became a household word. It was amazingâ€¦ I could type in some address and see what someone had to sell. Now it seems that everyone has an Internet site (if youâ€™re reading this, you know what I mean). How do you know that information that Iâ€™m providing is accurate? How should anyone confirm the authenticity of the information thatâ€™s out there?
If youâ€™ve read my soapbox article on e-mail, you know exactly what I mean. Ah, e-mail, that other great technological wonder! I can send a text message to anyone (and everyone) in a matter of seconds. Cool. And I can receive information from others just as quickly. Yes, I even receive those warnings about viruses and other dangerous maladies floating around (most, not all, are usually hoaxes).
Wait, there are web sites out there that warn of hoaxes, arenâ€™t there? Are kids learning this stuff in school? Are they learning how to verify the authenticity of their sources?
What else do computers teach children? What about word processing? Kids must learn how to write. But are they learning proper grammar? Does the word processing software that youâ€™re using always catch improper grammar usage? Even the software I use makes mistakes. I dislike the green squiggly lineâ€¦ itâ€™s annoying, and often incorrect. And how often does it remain stable? I enjoy rebooting my work computer every other week because my word processor is touchy. Youâ€™re probably thinking, “Brian, you should use Microsoft Word.” Newsflash: I do!
What about instant messaging? Does that have an effect on kidsâ€™ grammar today? If u r an IM user, u might recognize that Iâ€™m lol because of the stories I keep hearing about kids using IM “grammar” in their schoolwork. 🙂 Actually, itâ€™s pretty serious. If I were a teacher and a student of mine used IM abbreviations in any part of his or her paper, that kid would spend a lot of time after school with his or her nose in a novel (perhaps Dickens, possibly Tolstoy). :p
Another piece of software that I use regularly is a spreadsheet. This is an electronic (and if programmed properly, automated) ledger pad. Itâ€™s really convenient. I enter the numbers, apply a formula, and let the spreadsheet do its magic. If I need to change a number and recalculate the results, I change one number and let the spreadsheet perform the necessary calculation for me. But how many kids know how to set up a spreadsheet to do this? How many kids are going to need to know how to do this in their future professions? Personally, I canâ€™t see a doctor or lawyer using a spreadsheetâ€¦ thatâ€™s what aides and assistants are for.
But letâ€™s move away from what kids are learning in school and focus more on what theyâ€™re learning in general. They have technology in the classroom today. Computers, cable television, even dry-erase boards. Kids are taught that all of this great technology is needed to learn. What about imagination or really using your noodle? Whatâ€™s worse is whatâ€™s going on at home. Television flashes fast food as a fun thing and the coolest new toys and games during childrenâ€™s programming. Video games are readily available. Computers are invading homes everywhere.
All of this technology has led to one thing: fatter kids. The United States is the fattest country in the world. Even worse, over 30% of the fat people in the US are under 18! Obesity is becoming a bigger problem every year. It is the second largest contributor to heart disease and other fatal conditions (smoking is first), and it may soon become first. (To learn more, see the Center for Disease Control and Prevention website.)
Okay, so youâ€™re wondering how technology is doing this. Think about the hours kids spend sitting in front of the computer on the Internet, or sitting in front of the television playing video games or watching cartoons. Thatâ€™s hours that theyâ€™re not exercising.
Whatâ€™s worse is that children are playing games that are much more realistic in appearance (this ainâ€™t the Atari that I grew up with). With the amount of games that look realistic and have violent motifs, I wonder if kids are becoming desensitized to real life violence (Iâ€™ll leave the answer up to the folks that do the studies). Whatâ€™s worse is that the games are becoming racyâ€¦ I would never suggest Grand Theft Auto 3: Vice City for my nieces (what you do with your kids is your business)!
Iâ€™ve focused on children so far. What about adults? Does this technology affect us as well?
I believe it does. Iâ€™m just as guilty as the next person when it comes to watching television or chatting on the Internet (well, maybe not as guilty). Rather than being out and actually meeting people, I sit at home (to my credit, though, I probably spend more time working on the guitar than just sitting in front of the computer or television). But this means that Iâ€™m not as social as I should be or would like to be. But it also means that Iâ€™m not walking, exercising, etc. I even spend all day in an office sitting at a desk and often working on the computer. This translates into many hours of doing almost absolutely nothing that keeps my muscles in motion, and results in less calories burned.
Now what about other adults? Some other adults actually move around when they work, and come home to relax, right? Whatâ€™s wrong with that?
Actually, thereâ€™s nothing wrong with that, but itâ€™s whatâ€™s done when relaxing that bothers me. Most people sit at home, drink a couple of beers (or whatever), watch television, do a bit of housework, and go to bed. But there are a few people that spend countless hours on the computer and get nothing else done during that time. In that time, their kids are not getting help with their homework, their spouses are not getting the attention they need, and the house is falling into disarray (unless the spouse is doing work). As a result, adults are also getting larger.
Perhaps now is a good time to mention this: sitting truly messes up your back. I donâ€™t care what your chiropractor says. Sitting puts undue stress on the spine, causing most spines to lose natural curves in them. This results in putting pressure on the nerves in the spine (especially lower down the back). Your legs may hurt, your shoulders will droop forward and separate muscles in your neck, and your lower back will ache. The human body was not designed to sitâ€¦ I knew this back in college, and I know it now. Furthermore, repetitive motion injuries are becoming more prevalent among computer users.
This technology stuff is also a financial burden. For those of you who have money to burn, you can afford the latest and greatest (even though itâ€™s prone to crashing and stalling). For those of us who canâ€™t afford a new computer or television every year, we have to shell out cash every so often to have something that will last a while. My current computer cost me almost $2,000 only three years ago (case and monitor). My next one will cost more (due to specific needs), but wonâ€™t be purchased for at least a year (hmm, new computer for recording or Paul Reed Smith guitar?). My other option is to upgrade, but even that would cost at least $500.
What does this have to do with social degradation?
Because technology causes us to spend so much time and money on it, we run into problems elsewhere in our lives. I, for example, spend more time in front of my computer than trying to meet people. I also spend a considerable amount of money on computer software and peripherals instead of spending it on something more social (such as bars, clubs, bookstores, cafes, etc.). Needless to say, Iâ€™m still single!
Another area that’s leading to our demise is related to transportation. I’ll attack this from two fronts. First, there’s the “image” of the fast cars and sex appeal. People today are captivated by sports cars, driving fast, and lots of action, and most of us men think that it will help us pick up women (seeing how I’m a guy, I can’t speak for women). All of those flashy, glitzy images on the silver screen and the television lead us to think that we, too, can be flashy and glitzy by driving the same types of vehicles. So, we hop in our little sports cars, rev the engines, fly down roads at blazing speed, assuming we’ll never get caught, and -WHAMMO – you slam into a tree, another motorist, or a wall. If you’re smart, you chose to wear your seatbelt, in which case your car is toast but you are able to walk away or end up with a few minor injuries. If you’re not, you basically had a very quick lesson in physics as you flew through your windshield and died. Automotive safety technology has increased amazingly in the last thirty years, but our behaviors have also changed, making us feel invincible. The result is a record number of highway fatalities last year. The technology link? The glitz and glamour of movies and the media, and yes, even video games, contribute to this behavior.
On that note, I should also mention the increase in sports-utility vehicles (SUV). Not only are there more SUVs on the road today, but there are also more SUV rollovers. These vehicles are built high off the ground, which raises their centers of gravity and makes them more prone to rolling over when involved in an accident. Another contributing factor is the “invincibility” mentality I just mentioned above.
The second front deals with when we drive and where we drive to. Thanks to our desires to live in the middle of nowhere or to admire every moment we have in the car, we essentially drive everywhere. I’m just as guilty as the next person. Instead of taking a ten minute walk to the nearest grocery store, we hop in the car and drive to the store. Or, rather than allowing our kids to walk to school, we move 20 miles away and chauffer them to class, soccer, and all the other extracurricular activities they’re involved in, meaning that weâ€™re busier shipping our kids and dropping them off than spending quality time with them. But this behavior results in people becoming lazy, and laziness results in weight gain and obesity (you mean the kids should walk?). In the US, obesity is the second leading cause for premature deaths in the US (next to smoking), and may soon become number one. Although transportation is one cause, it’s not the only one. I also think other contributing factors include the way cities are planned (crossing the street in some areas is daunting due to high traffic levels), and non-active activities such as watching television or video games. But because transportation is so relatively cheap in the US (despite climbing gas prices, the rate of inflation of gas has declined over the last 20 yearsâ€¦ but that’s not the discussion here), using personal transportation instead of walking or finding other, more active means is making us fat.
Another problem is the increase in “greenhouse” emissions. Although cars today are emitting lower emissions, the cumulative effect is still dangerous. More people today have respiratory-related illnesses than ever before. And in many large cities in the US, smog and air pollution force states to perform annual or biennial emissions testing. Working from a budget perspective (and in the state Department of Transportation), I can guarantee that this is expensive. As a result, we are now inundated with reformulated fuels, which also cost more to produce. So there is also a financial impact, both at the government level, and the consumer level (which explains your higher gasoline prices). I could spend a lot more time discussing traffic congestion, the need to build more roads, and subsidized transit, but Iâ€™ll save that discussion for another day.
This is an excellent segway into cell phones. I hate how many people talk and drive on city streets (and in some cases on freeways). They seem more involved in the telephone conversation than on whatâ€™s going on in front of them. And they drive either very slowly or like maniacs. But what really bothers me is that many people donâ€™t pay attention to whatâ€™s going on in front of them. Although most studies show that a small percentage of accidents result from cell phone use, thereâ€™s another point to all of this. People donâ€™t pay attention when they drive. Technology has made things so convenient for us that we now rely on it to protect us, get us from point A to point B in record time, and do just about everything for us.
What really bothers me is when people talk on cell phones while theyâ€™re shopping. Okay, I donâ€™t have a problem with those that call a friend to determine if they should get the red dress or the blue one. However, I find it annoying when they carry on a fifteen minute conversation about everything but what theyâ€™re shopping for. Or worse, if youâ€™re a customer sales representative trying to help someone and they start a conversation on the phone, they expect you to wait for them until theyâ€™re conversation is overâ€¦ and it usually has nothing to do with his or her shopping trip. I have two words for people like that: voice mail! Even though these people are talking with others, theyâ€™re still being extremely rude and (dare I say it?) unsociable. I could talk about cell phone etiquette here, but Iâ€™d do better adding that to my e-mail article.
I want to sum up most of this with a legislative perspective. Because of the rapid growth of all of this technology, the government is having a tough time keeping up with it. Okay, I know most of you are worried about the “big brother” problem. But are you aware that because of the increase in bandwidth demand (cell phones with video and wi-fi) the airwaves are almost literally clogged with radio signals. The Federal Communications Commission has ordered rules that require television stations go digital, and other communication systems to move from one frequency to another. That means more expensive televisions and cell phone subscriptions (someone has to pay for it). Another problem is spam. Thereâ€™s so much of it now that several states are passing laws to limit it. And then thereâ€™s the problem with child pornography and parental oversight. Can you trust your neighbor on the Internet? Can you trust your kids (or, do you know where on the Internet your kids are)?
I think Iâ€™ve painted a pretty good picture of how technology is detrimental to all of us. Yes, there are positive benefits to technology, such as being a useful tool to make things more efficient for many users. Itâ€™s even a good idea to have a cell phone for emergencies. But technologyâ€™s instantaneous nature and quick convenience are having detrimental effects on society and on us. Weâ€™re not as friendly, weâ€™re getting lazier (and fatter), and we want everything now. Whatâ€™s worse, weâ€™re stressing out, some of us are dying prematurely, and itâ€™s costing us lots of money. Perhaps the Amish way of life could provide us some insights into how we should approach technologyâ€¦ but then I would have to give up my electric guitar and heavy metal!